summaryrefslogtreecommitdiff
path: root/doc/plugins/write/discussion.mdwn
blob: 039775b792308adf304e508fb5398c092cc44c78 (plain)

Maybe this is obvious, but the config variable lives in the IkiWiki module, and one probably wants to call defaultconfig for most applications.

[[DavidBremner]]

I'm a little concerned about one aspect of the %wikistate variable that was just introduced. I think global state for each plugin is a fine idea, but I worry about making it persist across rebuilds. (And by rebuild, I assume we're talking about the --rebuild option.)

My reasoning is that a 'rebuild' should be similar to checking out a new copy of the wiki and building. Another way of saying this is that all permanent state should be in the RCS. It is great that there is temporary state stored in other places - I think of it as indexing and caching. I'm worried that with the persistence, plugin writers will start putting data there that isn't backed by the RCS and that will break IkiWiki's great abilities as a distributed wiki.

[[Will]]

Well, if you look at state that already persists across rebuilds, we have pagectime, which can be extracted from RCS only very slowly in many cases. There's also the separate state stored by the aggregate plugin, which is indeed independant of the RCS, and can in some cases not be replecated by rebuilding a different checkout (if the data is gone from the feeds). Then there's the session cookie database, and the user database, which started out with a lot of local state, has been whittled down by removing admin prefs and subscriptions, but still has important state including password hashes.

So while I take your point about the potential for abuse, there's certianly legitimate reasons to need to store data across rebuilds. And plugins have always been able to drop their own files in wikistatedir as aggregate does and have it persist, so the abuse potential has always been there, the barrier has been lowered only slightly.

OTOH, if something can be added to the documentation that encourages good behavior, that'd be a good thing ... --[[Joey]]