The security of this plugin scares me. As noted in the plugin
documentation, you basically have to use it with SSL, since snooping on the
login password doesn't give you an essentially useless account -- it gives
you an actual account on the machine!
Also, apparently pwauth defers all auth attempts if one fails, and it
does this by using a lock file, and sleeping after a failed auth attempt.
Which is needed to avoid brute-forcing, since this is a significant
password.. but how will that interact with ikiwiki? Well, ikiwiki also
uses a lock file. So, at a minimum, someone can not only try to brute-force
the pwauth password, but the ikiwiki processes that stack up due to that
will also keep ikiwiki's lock held. Which basically DOSes the wiki for
everyone else; noone else can try to log in, or log out, or edit a page,
all of which require taking the lock.
So I don't think I'll be accepting this plugin into ikiwiki itself..
--[[Joey]]
Thanks for the comments. That's definitely an undesirable interaction between pwauth and ikiwiki; in my current application it wouldn't be a serious problem, but I'd like this plugin to be general-purpose and safe enough for inclusion in ikiwiki. It's the system-users-are-wiki-users idea I'm married to here, not pwauth itself; can you suggest another approach I might take?
-- [[schmonz]]
Have you considered using [[plugins/httpauth]] and then the appropriate apache module? There are apache modules like mod_authnz_external that might help. The advantage of these solutions is that they usually make the security implications explicit. -- Will
Actually, yes. That's how I made sure I had pwauth working to begin with. I'm partial to the form-based approach because I'm not aware of any way to reliably "log out" browsers from HTTP authentication. If that is reliably possible, then I worked way too hard for no reason. ;-)
-- [[schmonz]]
I've added support for checkpassword, since those generally don't have any rate-limiting cleverness to interfere with ikiwiki's, and made a few other changes. Please check out the plugin docs again and let me know if this is closer to being acceptable.
-- [[schmonz]]
I actually think that the rate limiting is a good thing. After all,
ikiwiki doesn't do its own login rate limiting. Just need to find a way
to disentangle the two locks. --[[Joey]]
Ah, ok, I misunderstood your comment. I'll see what I can figure out. --[[schmonz]]
