doc/bugs/comments_appear_two_times.mdwn



When a comment is added to page named "directory/page" it also appears in the page "directory".
This seems to happen at least with versions 3.20100815.6 and 3.20110225. Id didn't happen in version from about a year ago. I created a testing ikiwiki installation demonstrating this bug. The same comment can be seen at http://rtime.felk.cvut.cz/~sojka/blog/posts/directory/post/ and at http://rtime.felk.cvut.cz/~sojka/blog/posts/directory/. The corresponding git repo can be cloned by
git clone git://rtime.felk.cvut.cz/~sojka/blog.git


Unfortunatly, that git repo seems to be empty.
Perhaps you forgot to push to it? Thank you for working
to provide a way to reproduce this!
Myself, I cannot reproduce it. Eg, my blog has all posts
under http://kitenet.net/~joey/blog/entry/, but that page
shows none of the comments to my blog posts. And here on ikiwiki.info,
posts on the forum have comments, but they don't show up as comments
to the [[forum]] page.
--[[Joey]]


The repo can be cloned now. There was a problem with permissions. --[[wentasah]]


I see the bug now. Probably most configs hide it by setting
comments_pagespec more tightly. It was introduced by
d9d910f6765de6ba07508ab56a5a0f93edb4c8ad, and/or later
changes to actually use the comments() PageSpec.
Fixed in git! [[done]] --[[Joey]]