# Semantic Markdown Spec (Alpha Draft) [TOC] ## Introduction ### What is Semantic Markdown? Semantic Markdown is a plain-text format for writing documents that embed machine-readable data. The documents are easy to author and both human and machine-readable, so that the structured data contained within these documents is available to tools and applications. Technically speaking, Semantic Markdown is _"RDFa Lite for Markdown"_ and aims at enhancing the HTML generated from Markdown with [RDFa Lite] attributes. Design Rationale: - Embed RDFa-like semantic annotation within Markdown - Ability to mix unstructured human-text with machine-readable data in JSON-LD-like lists - Ability to semantically annotate an existing plain Markdown document with semantic annotations - Keep human-readability to a maximum ### About this document :::warning This document is in early draft stage ! ::: ### Providing feedback Interested in joining the idea or providing feedback? 1. Annotate this document with ideas 2. Join us on the [Semantic Markdown Matrix discussion channel](https://matrix.to/#/#semantic-markdown:matrix.virtual-assembly.org), e.g. using a client like Riot.im at https://riot.im/app/#/room/#semantic-markdown:matrix.virtual-assembly.org 3. Modify the document directly after your proposals were discussed ## Semantic Markdown at a glance Semantic annotations are declared within curly braces `{...}`. ### Annotation types Semantic Markdown provides 3 types of annotations: - annotating text with a type/class: Annotation starting with a `.` indicates a type/class, and generate RDFa `typeof` attribute: `{.foaf:Person}` - annotating text with a property: Annotation without leading marker indicates a property, and generate RDFa `property` attribute: `{foaf:name}` - annotating text with a subject identifier: Annotation starting with a `=` indicates an IRI of a known entity, and generate RDF `resource` attribute: `{=wdt:Q42}` ### Paragraph example ```markdown My name is [Manu Sporny]{:name} and you can give me a ring via [1-800-555-0199]{:telephone}. ![](http://manu.sporny.org/images/manu.png){:image} My favorite animal is the [Liger]{ov:preferredAnimal}. {=<#manu> .:Person} {schema}: @default {ov}: http://open.vocab.org/terms/ ``` Would produce the following HTML+RDFa: ```html

My name is Manu Sporny and you can give me a ring via 1-800-555-0199. My favorite animal is the Liger.

``` Notice how IRI namespace "schema" is implicitly resolved from its listing at [RDFa Core Initial Context] ### Title and list example ```markdown {.schema:Event} ## {schema:name} ## Specification meeting * Date: 11/10 {schema:startDate} * Place: Our office, Street name, Paris {schema:location} * Meeting participants: {schema:attendee} * Alice; * Bob; * [Tim](https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q80); * Description: Some information not annotated ## Launch party (TODO) {schema}: @default ``` Would produce the following HTML+RDFa: ```html

Specification meeting

Launch party

(TODO)

``` :::danger :heavy_exclamation_mark: FIXME: Undecided if final punctuation should be omitted ::: :::danger :heavy_exclamation_mark: FIXME: There is a problem in the RDFa markup as this generates _a single event with 2 names_ instead of 2 events each with a name (Thomas). Test the markup at http://rdfa.info/play ::: ## Annotation syntax Semantic Markdown is declared as sets of hints. Each set of hints is declared either directly where applied or indirectly tied to links. Hints may use shortened [CURIE][RDFa CURIE] notation, where uncommon vocabularies need to be defined. ### Hint syntax Semantic Markdown id written as a set of zero or more whitespace delimited hints, wrapped with curly braces `{...}`. Each hint consists of a type identifier and an address. Type identifier is either `.` or `=` or none. Address is either a IRI wrapped with angle brackets `<...>`, or an [RDFa CURIE]. All CURIEs must use either an [explicitly defined prefix](Prefix-definition-syntax) or a prefix listed in [RDFa Core Initial Context]. ### Link definition syntax :::warning :heavy_exclamation_mark: FIXME: write this... ::: ### Prefix definition syntax :::warning :heavy_exclamation_mark: FIXME: write this... ::: ## Annotation scopes Semantic Markdown is applied to content in different ways: ### Span scope Hints immediately following an explicitly confined span of text apply to the span; i.e. bare spans (square brackets: `[...]`), underline (underscore: `_..._`), emphasis (asterisk: `*...*`), strong emphasis (double asterisk: `**...**`), inline code (backticks: \`...\`), or link (square brackets + parenthesis: `[...](...)`). ```markdown My name is [Manu Sporny]{schema:name}. My name is **Manu [Sporny]**{schema:name}. My name is [Manu Sporny] {schema:name}. My name is Manu Sporny{schema:name}. ``` Would produce the following HTML+RDFa: ```html

My name is Manu Sporny
My name is Manu [Sporny]
My name is [Manu Sporny] {schema:name}
My name is Manu Sporny{schema:name}

``` Notice how third sentence above has no hints *immediately* following the span, and fourth sentence has no *explicit* span. ### Block scope Hints not immediately following an explicit span, in a block with non-whitespace characters before the hints and none after, applies to the block. ```markdown You can give me a ring. {=<#manu>} You can give me a ring {=<#manu>}. ``` Would produce the following HTML+RDFa: ```html

You can give me a ring.

You can give me a ring {=#manu}.

``` Notice how second paragraph has punctuation *after* the hints. ### Block-tree scope Hints in a block with non-whitespace characters after the hints and none before, applies to the block and any descendant blocks. If the resulting scope does not correspond to already generated html scope, then a div is added. In particular, when the resulting scope is the whole Markdown context then a Markdown parser targeting a full html document (not only a subset of body part as Markdown generally does) may apply the hints to the `` tag. ```markdown # People ## {=<#manu>} Manu Sporny My name is Manu Sporny. and you can give me a ring. ## Thomas Francart My name is Thomas Francart. ``` Would produce the following HTML+RDFa: ```html

People

Manu Sporny

My name is Manu Sporny, and you can give me a ring.

Thomas Francart

My name is Thomas Francart.

``` Notice how second header and succeeding paragraph is wrapped with a div tag, whereas third header is omitted because it is not a *descendant* but a *sibling*. ### Block-siblings scope Hints in a header or list block with no non-whitespace characters before or after the hints, followed by a block of same type and level, applies individually to each following block of same type and level, until any block of a lower level. ```markdown # People ## {.schema:Person} ## Manu Sporny My name is Manu Sporny. ## Thomas Francart My name is Thomas Francart. # Animals ``` Would produce the following HTML+RDFa: ```html

People

Manu Sporny

My name is Manu Sporny.

Thomas Francart

My name is Thomas Francart.

Animals

``` :::warning Insert example with a list ::: ### Block-cluster scope Hints in a block with no non-whitespace characters before or after the hints, followed by a different type or level of block, applies to the following block and any descendant blocks; or followed by a non-header non-list block, applies to the following block and any following siblings and any descendant blocks of any of them. If the resulting scope does not correspond to already generated html scope, then a div is added. In particular, when the resulting scope is the whole Markdown context then a Markdown parser targeting a full html document (not only a subset of body part as Markdown generally does) may apply the hints to the `` tag. ```markdown {.schema:Group} # People ## Manu Sporny My name is Manu Sporny. ## Thomas Francart My name is Thomas Francart. I once read this: > {=<#manu>} > My name is Manu Sporny. > > You can give me a ring. Should I call him? ``` Would produce the following HTML+RDFa: ```html

People

Manu Sporny

My name is Manu Sporny.

Thomas Francart

My name is Thomas Francart.

I once read this:

My name is Manu Sporny.

You can give me a ring.

Should I call him?

``` :::danger :heavy_exclamation_mark: FIXME: Uncertain which exact block types are considered descendant of which others. ::: ### Link definition scope Hints not immediately following an explicit span, in a link definition block with no non-whitespace characters after the hints, applies to all references to that definition, even if no link is defined. Similar to Markdown link definitions, source markup of this kind does not in itself result in any output html markup: It only affects _other_ markup, and if unused it simply is ignored. ```markdown My name is [Manu Sporny] and you can give me a ring via [1-800-555-0199]. [Manu Sporny]: {schema:name} [1-800-555-0199]: tel:+1-800-555-0199 "make a phone call to Manu Sporny" {schema:telephone} ``` Would produce the following HTML+RDFa: ```html

My name is Manu Sporny and you can give me a ring via 1-800-555-0199.

``` ## Semantic Markdown and other Markdown extensions ### Attributes extension See [PHP Markdown extra special attributes](https://michelf.ca/projects/php-markdown/extra/#spe-attr) and [Pandoc's header attributes](https://pandoc.org/MANUAL.html#heading-identifiers): Semantic Markdown uses similar syntax, but either with different leading character "=" or "keywords" containing a colon. Extract from PHP Markdown extra documentation: > With Markdown Extra, you can set the id and class attribute on certain elements using an attribute block. For instance, put the desired id prefixed by a hash inside curly brackets after the header at the end of the line, like this: > > ```markdown > Header 1 {#header1} > ======== > >## Header 2 ## {#header2} >``` >Then you can create links to different parts of the same document like this: > > ```markdown > [Link back to header 1](#header1) > ``` >To add a class name, which can be used as a hook for a style sheet, use a dot like this: >```markdown >## The Site ## {.main} >``` >You can also add custom attributes having simple values by specifying the attribute name, followed by an equal sign, followed by the value (which cannot contain spaces at this time): >```markdown >## Le Site ## {lang=fr} >``` >The id, multiple class names, and other custom attributes can be combined by putting them all into the same special attribute block: >```markdown >## Le Site ## {.main .shine #the-site lang=fr} >``` >At this time, special attribute blocks can be used with > - headers, > - fenced code blocks > - links, and > - images. ### spans See Pandoc [bracketed spans](https://pandoc.org/MANUAL.html#divs-and-spans) #### span example ```markdown Meeting with [Bob]{.foaf:Person} ``` Would produce the following HTML+RDFa: ```html

Meeting with Bob

``` ### blocks #### block example Annotations declared as a an initial separate block applies to all siblings by introducing a surrounding `
` tag. ```markdown {.schema:Event} We are preparing the [2020 Music Festival]{schema:name} ! ``` Would produce the following HTML+RDFa: ```html

We are preparing the 2020 Music Festival !

``` As per [Block scope](#Block-scope), Annotations declared at the end of a block (modulo whitespace) applies to that one block. ```markdown We are preparing the [2020 Music Festival]{schema:name} ! {.schema:Event} ``` Would produce the following HTML+RDFa: ```html

We are preparing the 2020 Music Festival !

``` ### Extend the extensions: use attributes at other places #### Set attributes on lists ```markdown - {foaf:member} - member 1 - member 2 - something else - member 3 ``` #### Set attributes on list items ```markdown - item 1 {foaf:member} - item 2 {foaf:member} - item 3 {foaf:member} ``` #### Set attributes on inlines ```markdown Thomas is _39_{foaf:age}. ``` ### Define a "property attribute" An attribute without `.`, without `#` and that is not a key-value pair should be recognized as a property name, e.g. `{foaf:name}`. ### Define a "subject attribute" An attribute beginning with the `=` sign indicates a subject IRI, equivalent to an `resource=xxx` property, e.g. `{=wdt:Q42}` is equivalent to `` ## Annotate properties (RDFa "property" attribute) ### Properties in lists #### Key/Value pairs If the list item contains `:` or `=`, the annotation is applied to the string after this character. ```markdown - Name: Thomas Francart {foaf:name} - Age = 39 {foaf:age} - Profession: Semantic Web Consultant; {rdfs:comment} - Hobby: Bird watching; train spotting; {rdfs:comment} ``` Should yield (note how semi-colons are excluded from last annotations): ```html ``` :::danger :heavy_exclamation_mark: FIXME: Undecided if punctuation exceptions for lists should be included ::: :::danger :heavy_exclamation_mark: FIXME: Undecided if final punctuation should be omitted ::: #### Value-only list items ```markdown - Thomas Francart {foaf:name} - 39 {foaf:age} - Semantic Web Consultant {rdfs:comment} ``` Should yield ```html ``` #### Annotate a list with a property Annotating a list with a property annotation should be treated as if all list items are annotated with the same property ```markdown {foaf:member} - Thomas ; - Vincent; - Nicolas; ``` Is equivalent to ```markdown - Thomas; {foaf:member} - Vincent; {foaf:member} - Nicolas; {foaf:member} ``` And should yield ```html ``` :::danger :heavy_exclamation_mark: FIXME: Undecided if final punctuation should be omitted ::: ### Inline properties #### Properties on inline delimiters ```markdown Thomas is [39]{foaf:age}. ``` Should yield ```html

Thomas is 39

``` Same with `_`, `*` or `**`. ### Annotate with 2 properties It should be possible to annotate with 2 properties ```markdown - Name: Alice {foaf:name rdfs:label} - Age: 23 {foaf:age} ``` Should yield ```html - Name: Alice - Age: 23 ``` ## Annotate the subject of properties ### Use a class attribute (RDFa "typeof" attribute) ```markdown # Le site {.foaf:Document} ``` Would produce the following HTML+RDFa: ```

Le site

``` As per [Block scope](#Block-scope), above hints applies to an existing block which serves as placeholder for the semantic hints, and there is therefore no need for adding a wrapper `
` tag. ```markdown {.foaf:Document} - item 1 - item 2 - item 3 ``` Would produce the following HTML+RDFa: ```html
  • item 1
  • item 2
  • item 3
``` (Note that the `typeof` RDFa attribute used alone generates an anonymous node as the current subject of inner `property` attributes. In other words, further property annotations will refer to an entity of the provided type.) ### Use an ID attribute (RDFa "resource" attribute) Use an annotation starting with "=" ```markdown # Douglas Adams {=wdt:Q42} ``` :::danger :heavy_exclamation_mark: FIXME: Undecided if leading character `=` should be replaced with e.g. `@`or `#`. ::: ### Combine ID + class It should be possible to combine an ID and a type attribute ```markdown His name is [Douglas Adams]{.foaf:Person =wdt:Q42} {wdt}: http://www.wikidata.org/prop/direct/ ``` Should produce the following HTML+RDFa ```html

His name is Douglas Adams

``` But beware that if one hint is broken then the whole annotation is passed through as-is, e.g. if using an undefined prefix: ```markdown His name is [Douglas Adams]{.foaf:Person =wdt:Q42} ``` Should produce the following HTML+RDFa ```html

His name is [Douglas Adams]{.foaf:Person =wdt:Q42}

``` ## Where to find the current subject? RDFa relies on a mechanism to indicate the [_current subject_ of the annotation](https://www.w3.org/TR/rdfa-core/#setting-the-current-subject). Semantic Markdown aims at having an equivalent mechanism. Intuitively, the current subject is the resource annotated in the "closest ancestor" of a property annotation. ### Current span subject Used to indicate that a certain inline portion of a sentence is about an entity. ```markdown [Tim Berners Lee]{=wdt:Q80} invented the web. {wdt}: http://www.wikidata.org/prop/direct/ ``` Should yield ```html

Tim Berners Lee invented the web.

``` ### Current paragraph subject Used to indicate that a whole paragraph is about an entity. The annotation is at the end of the paragraph for readability. ```markdown Tim Berners Lee invented the web. {=wdt:Q80} {wdt}: http://www.wikidata.org/prop/direct/ ``` Should yield ```html

Tim Berners Lee invented the web.

``` ### Current list subject Used to indicate that a whole list describes an entity. The annotation should be sought at the end of the line preceding the list. ```markdown {=wdt:Q80} - Name: Tim Berner's Lee {foaf:name} - ISNI: 0000 0000 7866 6209 {wd:P213} {wdt}: http://www.wikidata.org/prop/direct/ {wd}: http://www.wikidata.org/entity/ ``` Should yield ```html
  • Name: Tim Berner's Lee
  • ISNI: 0000 0000 7866 6209
``` :::warning :heavy_exclamation_mark: FIXME: Undecided if punctuation exceptions for lists should be included ::: ### Paragraph preceding a list If an annotation is between a paragraph and a list, then it applies to the list when standalone with double newlines same as writing a separate paragraph: ```markdown The web was invented by this geek: {=wdt:Q80} - Name: Tim Berner's Lee {foaf:name} - ISNI: 0000 0000 7866 6209 {wd:P213} {wdt}: http://www.wikidata.org/prop/direct/ {wd}: http://www.wikidata.org/entity/ ``` Should yield ```html

The web was invented by this geek:

  • Name: Tim Berner's Lee
  • ISNI: 0000 0000 7866 6209
``` ```markdown {.schema:Event} * Date: 11/10 {schema:startDate} * Meeting participants: {schema:attendee} * Alice; * Bob; ``` :::warning :heavy_exclamation_mark: FIXME: unclear if example is relevant ::: ### Indented lists Indented lists are key because they could make plain Markdown lists look like JSON-LD trees; Plain Markdown list: ```markdown Here is our meeting description: - Date: 10/11/2019 - Location: somewhere - Attendees: - Alice - Engineer - Works for: Foo - Hobbies: - Football - Video games - Bob - Sales Manager - Works for: Bar - Hobbies: - Cooking - Cycling ``` Annotated version: ```markdown Here is our meeting description: {.schema:Event} - Date: 10/11/2019 {schema:startDate} - Location: somewhere {schema:place} - Attendees: {schema:attendee} - Alice {schema:name} - Engineer {schema:jobTitle} - Works for: Foo {schema:affiliation} - Hobbies: {schema:knowsAbout} - Football - Video games - Bob {schema:name} - Sales Manager {schema:jobTitle} - Works for: Bar {schema:affiliation} - Hobbies: {schema:knowsAbout} - Cooking - Cycling ``` :::danger :heavy_exclamation_mark: FIXME: Either replace this section with JSON-LD like style or drop this section ::: ### Current blockquote subject Used to indicate that a blockquote describes an entity :::danger :heavy_exclamation_mark: FIXME: Either document how or drop this section ::: ### Current header subject Used to indicate that a certain section of a document describes an entity. The following annotated MD: ```markdown ## {=ex:AliceIRI} Description of Alice She is [23]{foaf:age} and lives in [Berlin]{foaf:basedNear}. {ex}: http://example.org/ ``` Should produce the following HTML+RDFa: ```html

Description of Alice

She is 23 and lives in Berlin

``` Similarly ```markdown ## {.schema:Event} Specification meeting - Date: 10/11/2019 {schema:startDate} - Location: somewhere {schema:location} ``` Should produce the following HTML+RDFa: ```html

Specification meeting

  • Date: 10/11/2019
  • Location: somewhere
``` ### Current div subject ```markdown {=wdt:Q80} Tim Berners Lee invented the web. He now works on Solid. {wdt}: http://www.wikidata.org/prop/direct/ ``` Should yield ```html

Tim Berners Lee invented the web.

He now works on Solid.

``` As per [Block-cluster scope](#Block-cluster-scope), hints applies until next descendant block or sibling paragraph. To limit without introducing new content, use an empty hint: ```markdown {=wdt:Q80} Tim Berners Lee invented the web. He now works on Solid. {} A paragraphe after the div ended. {wdt}: http://www.wikidata.org/prop/direct/ ``` Should yield ```html

Tim Berners Lee invented the web.

He now works on Solid.

A paragraphe after the div ended.

``` ## Declaring prefixes Declare [prefix definitions](#Prefix-definition-syntax), anywhere in the document, preferably at the end to ease readability. ```markdown {.schema:Event} * Date: 10/11/2019 {schema:startDate} * Location{.ex:good_places}: somewhere {schema:location} {schema}: http://schema.org/ {rdfs}: http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema# {ex}: http://example.org/ ``` Should yield ```html
  • Date: 10/11/2019
  • Location: somewhere
``` Notice how prefixes "schema" and "rdfs" are omitted, because they are implicitly defined by [RDFa Core Initial Context], and rdfs also because it is unused. :::danger :heavy_exclamation_mark: FIXME: Undecided if prefix declared in the source should always be converted in the output or omitted if unneeded as per Core Initial Context or when unused. ::: :::danger :heavy_exclamation_mark: FIXME: The example is inconsistent as it defines 2 properties in the second li : `
  • Location: somewhere
  • ` ::: ### Prefix and link definitions have similar but separate syntax Prefixes mimic the syntax for links, but using curly brackets instead of angle brackets: ```markdown ### Specifications Meeting {.schema:Event} * Date: 10/11/2019 {.schema:startDate} Bla bla bla as is documented in the [schema] ontology. — [schema]: http://schema.org/ {schema}: http://schema.org/ {rdfs}: http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema# ``` ### Specifying the default prefix Declaring a prefix as the default generates a `vocab` attribute instead of a prefix on the outermost block of the text, adding a div if no such block exists already. All uses of that default prefix is then generated without a prefix. ```markdown My name is [Alice]{ex:name}. {ex}: http://example.org/ @default ``` Would produce the following HTML+RDFa: ```html

    My name is Alice

    ``` :::danger FIXME : The default namespace should make it possible to annotate the document without using a prefix at all. Instead of giving the default both a prefix name _and_ a special annotation, I suggest using `@default` as the prefix itself. ```markdown My name is [Alice]{name}. {@default}: http://example.org/ ``` Would produce the following HTML+RDFa: ```html

    My name is Alice

    ``` ::: ### Common prefixes are implicitly defined All prefixes predefined in [RDFa Core Initial Context] can be used without explicitly defining them. ```markdown My name is [Alice]{schema:name}. ``` Would produce the following HTML+RDFa: ```html

    My name is Alice

    ``` ## Referring to a IRI ### Absolute IRI reference with <> `Meeting with [Bob]{.}` ### CURIE (with a declared prefix) ```markdown Meeting with [Bob]{.f:Person} {f}: http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/ ```` ---- ## Parallel Idea: Indented Lists using Link References (JSON-LD or YAML-like lists). ```markdown ## {.schema:Event} Bird watchers meeting - [Date]: 10/11/2019 - [Location]: somewhere - [Attendees]: - [Name]: Alice - [jobTitle]: Engineer - [Works for]: Foo - [Hobbies]: - Football - Video games - [Name]: Bob - [jobTitle]: Sales Manager - [Works for]: Bar - [Hobbies]: - Cooking - Cycling [Date]: {schema:startDate} [Location]: {schema:Location} [Name]: {schema:name} [jobTitle]: {schema:jobTitle} [Works for]: {schema:affiliation} [Hobbies]: {schema:knowsAbout} ``` Link can optionally be made clickable by adding a link to its definition at the bottom. # See also http://rdfa.info/ Whereas the scope of this project is limited to authoring a specification and maybe developing proof-of-concept parsers for it, some projects doing similar or more than that can be of inspiration. [Roam-research](https://roamresearch.com/) [Org-roam](https://org-roam.readthedocs.io/en/master/) [TiddlyRoam](https://joekroese.github.io/tiddlyroam/) There is also some experimentations on how to use those specifications: [SemanticMarkdown use cases studies](https://hackmd.io/yrm6X38NQTG6X-g6eyNt_g) Other references : [RDFa Lite] [RDFa CURIE] [RDFa Core] [RDFa Core Initial Context] [RDFa Lite]: https://www.w3.org/TR/rdfa-lite/ [RDFa CURIE]: https://www.w3.org/TR/rdfa-core/#s_curies [RDFa Core Initial Context]: https://www.w3.org/2011/rdfa-context/rdfa-1.1 [RDFa Core]: https://www.w3.org/TR/rdfa-core/ --- # Deprecated Stuff #### Attributes on a word without inline delimiters? ```markdown Thomas is 39{foaf:age}. ``` #### Properties on word without delimiters If a property annotation immediately follows a word with no explicit inline delimiters, it should be applied to this word only. (Is it really possible in terms of parsing? don't know). ```markdown Thomas is 39{foaf:age}. ``` Should yield ```html

    Thomas is 39

    ``` #### IRI written directly as key ```markdown - foaf:name: Thomas Francart - foaf:age = 39 - rdfs:comment: Semantic Web Consultant ``` Should yield ```html
    • foaf:name: Thomas Francart
    • foaf:age = Thomas Francart
    • rdfs:comment: Semantic Web Consultant
    ```